The 'novelty' of arXiv overlay journals

Last September, Nature published an article on a new publishing initiative by Timothy Gowers. The Nature piece starts thus:

"New journals spring up with overwhelming, almost tiresome, frequency these days. But Discrete Analysis is different. This journal is online only — but it will contain no papers. Rather, it will provide links to mathematics papers hosted on the preprint server arXiv. Researchers will submit their papers directly from arXiv to the journal, which will evaluate them by conventional peer review."

and ends as follows:

"The question, perhaps, is how readily researchers will embrace the model. “Apart from being an arXiv overlay journal, our journal is very conventional, which I think is important so that mathematicians won't feel it is too risky to publish in it,” says Gowers. “But if the model becomes widespread, then I personally would very much like to see more-radical ideas tried out as well” — for example, post-publication review and non-anonymous referees."

Based on the first paragraph of this blog post by Timothy Gowers, it is highly likely that Discrete Analysis will start by publishing some very strong papers. This will probably play an important role in enticing mathematicians to publish some of their best work in it and in giving the new journal a good impact factor within a reasonable amount of time.

However, as mentioned in the Nature piece and as Gowers himself pointed out in his blog post announcing Discrete Analysis, arXiv overlay journals are not new. In TCS, Logical Methods in Computer Science published its first issue ten years ago and has become one of the favourite publication outlets for researchers working on logic in computer science, broadly construed. Logical Methods in Computer Science is an open-access journal, covered by Thompson ISI , SCOPUS, DBLP, Mathematical Reviews and Zentralblatt. (Impact factor: 0.443.) All journal content is licensed under a Creative Commons license.

Moreover, the 'arXiv overlay principle' is also used by Electronic Proceedings in Theoretical Computer Science (EPTCS), an international refereed open access venue for the rapid electronic publication of the proceedings of workshops and conferences, and of Festschriften, etc, in the general area of theoretical computer science, broadly construed. This proceedings series, which was initiated in 2008-2009 by the sterling effort of Rob van Glabbeek, has published 200 volumes at the time of writing this blog post. (Congrats to EPTCS for reaching the milestone of 200 volumes!)

Just like Discrete Analysis will do, Logical Methods in Computer Science (and EPTCS for workshops and conferences) only publishes papers that have undergone classic peer review and have been vetted for publication by the cognizant editor. For what it is worth, I therefore fail to see why Logical Methods in Computer Science and Discrete Analysis, once it starts publishing papers, are not doing journal publishing, as hinted in this excerpt from a post from the scholarly kitchen:

"My view is that while this is a fascinating way to draw out from arXiv links to good preprints in relevant fields, this is not journal publishing. In Gower’s blog he moves on from talking about the idea of the overlay journal to a more polemical discussion of how his venture is in essence the future of the journal, reducing costs and supplying quality content in a way that may be used in the same way journal articles are used now. While Gowers has every right to his views on this, I would argue that, while his is certainly an exciting way to make use of preprints in arXiv, what it does is quite distinct from a journal. As discussed above, the journal is a matter of record, and like it or not, journals form a part of the academic and recognition workflow that allows for career progress, grant making, more research and more articles to be published."

Logical Methods in Computer Science is "a matter of record", and publishing in it does carry weight in hiring and promotion decisions. Prime conferences in the field, such as LICS, have used it for their special issues.

Whether a journal publishes its contents as overlay of the arXiv or by some other means, IMHO it is the process that went into selecting the papers and the scientific quality of what is published that matter.